The Shift Away From Hostile Mobs?

As the updates have marched onwards, I have noticed something. With the exception of the Nether Update, we are seeing a trend towards more passive mobs and fewer hostile mobs being added.

Before I get into the main body of the rant, I just want to give a disclaimer: In this article, I will be talking about the mobs as either passive or hostile. "Technically neutral" mobs that are mostly hostile, like the Piglin, will be regarded as hostile, and neutral mobs that are mostly passive, like the Goat or Bee, will be regarded as passive.

Number Crunching
So first, let's look back in time to what kind of mobs were being added, and what the balance of passive and hostile mobs was.

For much of Minecraft's history, hostile mobs have outnumbered passive mobs. Sometimes quite considerably. Let's look at Minecraft update 1.4.2, which was the first update that released after I started playing. At that time, there were 30 mobs in Minecraft, not counting Jockeys. By my considerations, 18 were hostile, and 12 were passive. I have found that to generally be the case for much of Minecraft's history. The gap may have closed a bit after 1.6 due to the addition of several passive mobs, but then came 1.8 which added 3 hostile mobs and 1 passive mob. 1.9 added 2 hostile mobs and NO passive mobs, 1.10 added 2 hostile mobs and an.. umm.. Polar Bear... and 1.11 added 3 hostile mobs and 1 passive mob. Following on from these updates, we were at 28 hostile mobs and 18 passive mobs (these numbers are give or take a couple depending on what you count as a separate mob).

After this, however, there was a shift towards more passive mobs and fewer hostile mobs.

1.12 added a single passive mob (the Illusioner doesn't count as it was never implemented proper). 1.13 added MANY passive mobs, with 6 passive mobs and 2 hostile. 1.14 also added more passive mobs, with 4 passive mobs and 2 hostiles. 1.15 added the Bee, which for this rant I am considering passive. 1.16 was the obvious exception, being the Nether Update and all, but even this update added a passive mob (and 4 hostiles). But after the Nether Update, we see an almost total disappearance of hostile mobs. 1.17 added 3 passive mobs and no hostiles, 1.18 added no mobs at all, and 1.19... well... if we're counting the Tadpole and Fireflies as mobs, we are currently slated to see 4 passive mobs and 1 hostile mob: the Warden.

In fact, the Warden is the first hostile mob we have seen since Piglin Brutes, almost 2 years ago!

We came to 1.11 with 28 hostiles and 18 passives. Updates after 1.11 have added 19 passive mobs and just 9 hostiles. This brings us to a total of... 37 passives... and 37 hostiles. Yup. For the first time probably EVER, there are as many passive mobs as there are hostile mobs. And if this trend continues, the passive mobs will outnumber the hostile mobs probably for the first time since before hostile mobs were a thing.

If I were looking at fewer updates here, one could attribute this stark trend to cherry-picking, but I do not believe this to be the case. I have drawn the line after 1.11, which gives us 8 updates to look at. In terms of number of Minecraft Updates and the amount of content in these 8 updates (there is probably more in 1 update nowadays than all of the Beta updates combined!) I do believe this to be significant. It's 5 and a half years of development, almost half the game's history.

And if you want more proof of this trend away from hostile mobs, look at the Minecraft Mob Votes. In 2017, all four of the mobs in the mob vote were hostile mobs. In 2021, they were all helpful, friendly, "CIIIEEEWWWWT" mobs. In fact, the Glare's entire damn selling point was that it was cute. Which I don't think it is.

Okay, so I've shown there definitely HAS been a trend away from hostile mobs. Not only are passive mobs being added more often than ever, hostile mobs are being added LESS often than ever. But why could this be? Why is there this trend?

C***
If you've seen ANY Mojang production, you have probably heard the C-word many, MANY times. No not See You Next Tuesday. I'm talking about See You Tuesday, Ethel. Cute.

Minecraft over the years has become less and less scary, and more and more cute. Many of the more recent updates and mobs have been focused on making cute mobs rather than scary ones. Even the WARDEN was described as "cute" several times by the Mojang team. Scary-cute. Derpy-cute. Cuteness overload!

It is known that in its early days, Minecraft was a fairly scary and combat-driven game. In the days before sprinting, you could do nothing to outrun your enemies, and a simple skeleton could be your doom. In the days of Notch, there was definitely more of a focus on combat, strategy, and a fear factor. "Cute" was certainly not a priority with Notch. But in the latest few updates, when there has been a shift towards adding more and more animal mobs to the game, the C-word has been thrown around a whole lot more. The size of the Bees was chosen to "optimise cuteness". Striders? "Ugly-cute". Axolotls? Cute. Goats? Cute. Just about every passive mob that has been added since the Bees has been described as "cute".

It's also obvious that Mojang have been adding more and more animal mobs to the game in order to try and raise awareness for certain endangered species. Pandas, Axolotls, Turtles, Dolphins, and even Bees, all were added with raising awareness in mind. That's all well and good, but where are the new monsters? Minecraft was always part-real, part-fantasy. But only so many mobs can be added in an update, and when most of them are real-life animals, what room does that leave for the fantasy element? The monsters?

Final Word
I get that everyone has different playstyles, and for some people this shift towards passive mobs is a welcome change. I never said this shift was inherently a BAD thing... but I am an adventurer, and I am running out of monsters to fight. And with fewer and fewer monsters and more and more animals being added in almost all updates, the game essentially just starts to feel like a simulation of real life than the fantasy game it used to be. And while new fantasy elements are still sometimes added, such as Sculk, it feels these bold fantasy moves are occurring less and less often. Was there any fantasy element in Caves & Cliffs other than Glow Squid and Glow Berries?

All in all, I feel we've had so few new hostile mobs lately, and the game could really benefit from some new dangers at this point.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ambient Mobs.... Are They a BAD Thing?

Bat Bad? Since its addition in 2012, the Bat has become the subject of much opprobrium as the most pointless and useless mob in Minecraft. Serving absolutely no purpose other than existing and flying in your face, no drops, no XP, broken AI... many have questioned why this mob was even created in the first place. Heck, in my complete ranking of all mobs in Minecraft, I ranked bats as the 2nd WORST mob in Minecraft, 2nd only to the Endermite!  The Bat is the only mob in Minecraft that is purely, 100% ambient. It has absolutely no greater purpose or drops. It doesn't interact with the player in any way or have any mechanics. Even the Endermite drops XP on death, the Bat drops none. It serves literally NO purpose other than to just be there and add some atmosphere to caves. Part of why the Bat is so hated and ostracised may be because it is the only mob that is truly 100% "useless", and is one the player will encounter often. Every time we see it, it reminds us that it is tr...
Read more

The 12 Most DANGEROUS Places in Minecraft

If you're trying to escape the dangers of planet Earth in post-2019, Minecraft Survival may not be the place to go. Between exploding plant monsters, surface lava and literal hell itself, the world of Minecraft is far from safe. There is no fast-mutating killer virus that is more catching than a cold, but there are undead bone men who should have an Olympic gold platinum diamond medal in archery. If it's safety you want, let's explore the places in your Minecraft world you should probably NOT go, especially unprepared. 12 - Outside at Night This one is a given. The Overworld once the sun falls is certainly not a safe place to be, being absolutely surrounded by hostile mobs of various types. What makes this so much more apparent than others much higher on the list is how early-game this is encountered. You will find yourself outside at night within the first TEN minutes, leaving you very unprepared and vulnerable. However, being outside at night is this low on the list becau...
Read more

How the Trident Failed to Become a Viable Tool in Minecraft

I'll be blunt: I struggle to think of a feature with as much wasted potential as the trident. The first actual new weapon added to Minecraft in almost its entire history, you would think the addition of the trident would have been absolutely MASSIVE. And it certainly was... for all of a few weeks until the novelty wore off. 9 melee damage compared to the Diamond Sword's 7 certainly seemed good, as did the fact it also has a ranged attack doing 8 damage per hit and moving freely through water. It seemed good on paper, but it quickly became apparent that the trident had many issues which stopped it from being practical. In this rant I will discuss what went wrong with the trident, and why it hasn't found its way into very many survival playthroughs. And bear in mind, I am talking about the trident as of 21w14a (1.17). A few changes have been made in the combat snapshots, but the combat snapshots have yet to appear in an actual version of Minecraft. Strap yourselves in, this i...
Read more